papertigers.org
home book reviews
 

Intro

Canada
  China
UK
USA

 
   

Is this section useful?
Are we missing something?
Let us know!

feedback At Papertigers Dot Org

sign up for our newsletter!

read our blog



 
 

United Kingdom

Reviews from
 Books for Keeps
 
   < View all Books for Keeps reviews
 

Rating: *** 3 stars

Manju Gregory, illustrated by David Anstey,
Jill and the Beanstalk.
Mantra.

Jack's sister, Jill, plays the lead role in this version of the familiar tale. Jack is in bed, nursing his head after falling down the hill. The story is told in rhyme with allusions to various (mostly well-known) nursery rhymes dotted throughout for the reader to pick out. All the nursery rhymes alluded to are helpfully supplied, in full, at the end of the book. The beginning sets the scene superbly: 'Jack climbed a hill with his sister Jill./ Jack fell down and now he's ill./ There's nothing to eat, they're feeling sad./ If only the giant hadn't swallowed their dad.' So of course, it's up to Jill to sell the cow and embark on the adventures that Jack would have been destined for had he not hurt his head. The rest of the story follows the course of events familiar to us, all told in rhyme.

It's a clever idea, imaginatively illustrated (I particularly like Anstey's depcition of the giant, a combination of pirate and clown) and is likely to have instant appeal. It's a title you want to pick up and look at. Providing a translation for a story in rhyme must be quite a challenge - I always wonder how successfully it's been achieved. (Available in 22 dual language editions.)

Urmi Chana

Guide to the rating system:
***** 5 stars, unmissable
**** 4 stars, very good
*** 3 stars, good
** 2 stars, fair
* 1 star, poor
back to top

 

 

 

  personal views | reviews | lists and links | interviews | gallery | resources | pt outreach  
   
 

about us | downloads | site map | search | testimonials | pt blog
contact us©2006 Pacific Rim Voices