| Rating:
**** 4 stars
Rob Bowden,
The Ganges.
Series A River Journey, Hodder
Wayland, 2003.
(reviewed with Simon Scoones, The Amazon,
same series and publisher)
Two great rivers, each loaded with picturesque images,
and each the home of blind dolphins, are traced from
source to delta. The organising of their texts under
the headings Nature, History, People, Economy and
Change enables the authors to deal in concise detail
with different aspects of these headings as we meander
down river, and lets the reader follow one particular
strand at a time without having to ramble through
too much fascinating irrelevance. The device is called
‘Themed Text’.
Amazon chooses to start at historic
Machu Picchu. We visit the car-free Iquitos, lament
the dismal contribution and fate of early missionaries,
learn the impact of the oil and mining industries,
and fear for the future of the forest of whose nature
we are plentifully informed.
Ganges - life-giver to Northern
India, death-bringer to Bangladesh, receives similar
treatment and much space is devoted to its overt religious
significance. In Bangladesh ‘peddle-powered’
rickshaws splash through the flooding delta.
Excellent photographs and simple relevant maps enliven
and reinforce two strong texts, and the ‘theme’
idea works well, enabling the books to be read in
series as well as in parallel. It seems we can also
look forward to the Nile, Rhine, Mississippi and Yangtze.
Ted Percy
Guide to the rating system:
***** 5 stars, unmissable
**** 4 stars, very good
*** 3 stars, good
** 2 stars, fair
* 1 star, poor
|